Senator Vogel (R) Sponsors Bill that will Endager Seniors

cheerful middle aged woman embracing disabled senior mother outd

June 15 is World Elder Abuse Awareness Day. It was launched  by the World Health Organization and the United Nations and International Network for the Prevention of Elder Abuse. This day is observed to provide an opportunity for communities around the world to promote a better understanding of abuse and neglect of the elderly by raising awareness of the economic, cultural, and social processes that contribute elder abuse and neglect.

Ironically, in the same month which has been dedicated to elder abuse awareness, Senator Elder Vogel (R) has sponsored a bill that could needlessly endanger thousands of senior citizens in Pennsylvania. Vogel is the prime sponsor of Senate Bill 747 which calls for a cap on punitive damages against assisted living facilities and long-term care nursing homes. Punitive damages are meant to punish reckless and wanton conduct. It would limit punitive damages to 200% of the compensatory damages awarded.

This is significant because the threat of punitive damages is the only real incentive motivating nursing homes to provide high quality care to our parents and grandparents.  This is because the typical nursing home claimant has no meaningful compensatory damages. Instead, the only way a resident and their families can obtain redress for the harm caused to them is through punitive damages.

If passed, this bill will jeopardize the health and safety of Pennsylvania’s most vulnerable citizens by allowing the nursing home industry to operate with impunity. Contrary to popular belief, most nursing homes are not non-profit or run by religious organizations. Instead, this is a multi-billion dollar industry dominated by nursing homes which are run by large for-profit companies. For-profit nursing home facilities are notorious for under-staffing homes and cutting resources to razor this levels in order to reap huge profits.

As a nursing home abuse lawyer, I’ve heard more than my share of horror stories from family members of nursing home residents who have suffered heartbreaking neglect and abuse as a result of understaffed nursing homes or inhumane treatment. It is puzzling to this writer why Senator Vogel wants to limit damages meant to punish bad behavior that is inflicted on elderly and defenseless nursing home residents.

Contact Your State Senator and Voice Your Opposition to Senate Bill 747

I encourage anyone who reads this article and wants to protect the rights, health and safety of senior citizens to contact their state senator to explain why this bills is bad for Pennsylvania. Tell them that elder abuse and neglect will not be tolerated.

I have reached out to Senator Farnese in my district, as well as several other senators. A copy of my message to Senator Farnese is included below.

Dear Senator Farnese –

I’m writing in regards to Senate Bill 747 which imposes a cap on punitive damages against nursing homes. As a nursing home abuse attorney, I know the only thing that motivates nursing homes to hire sufficient staff and provide quality care is the fear of punitive damages. This bill is a step in the wrong direction for Pennsylvania’s most vulnerable residents. It would allow nursing homes to operate with impunity, as they would not be held accountable for even the most egregious violations.
Please do the right thing and take a stand against this bill.
Thank you.
Brent Wieand
P.O. Box 30457
Philadelphia, PA 19103



Schedule free consultation
Get Started Today!